What is our obligation when it comes to withholding or divulging information? The Torah prohibits tale bearing, but it also requires us to rebuke those among us who engage in problematic behavior. Furthermore, we may not stand idly by when someone may come to harm if we do not reveal hidden truths. This delicate balance between to tell or not to tell is worth exploring in the context of Jewish sources with an eye towards the tremendous challenge presented by global social media platforms.